Coming Out: Fibromyalgia by Beth Winegarner

“When we feel vulnerable sharing something with someone, I think it’s because we are actually judging or shaming ourselves ... And then we’re afraid the other person will as well. We’re afraid they will confirm our worst fears about ourselves. That’s why it’s scary. We fear their rejection because we’re really fearing our own rejection of ourselves.” —Kara Loewenthiel

“The reward for conformity is that everyone likes you but yourself.” —Rita Mae Brown

I have fibromyalgia.

I was formally diagnosed a couple of years ago, but I’ve been living with it in some form since my early 20s. For years I thought it might be something else: rheumatoid arthritis, maybe, or a connective-tissue disorder. The diagnosis surprised me, but over time it has come to make sense. 

The definition of fibromyalgia, as it stands now (the medical world doesn’t really understand it very well yet), is that it’s a neurological condition in which things that shouldn’t hurt do, and things that should only hurt a little hurt a lot. When I injure myself, my body heals but the pain lingers — my nervous system “learns” the pain, then struggles to unlearn it. Fibromyalgia often comes with fatigue, general aches, brain fog, trouble sleeping and other symptoms. For everyone who has it, it’s a bit different. 

This is what it’s like for me: I’m in a little bit of pain every day, somewhere in my body. Often, it’s more than a little pain. Today, it’s focused in a spot next to my right shoulder blade. But I’m achy elsewhere, too — in my shoulders, my arms, my legs, my feet. Sometimes, I also feel like I’m coming down with the flu: my throat and eyes are scratchy, everything aches and I feel like I could sleep for days. I have one or two days like that each month. Even on a good day, my body gets stiff quickly, and standing up when I’ve been sitting a while means walking gingerly until my muscles joints loosen again. 

Fibromyalgia flares often come on when I overdo it, physically or emotionally. If I spend an hour gardening or take a long walk, or even if just have a night of bad sleep, I’ll have flu-like symptoms the next day. It’s similar if I get really upset or stressed out by something. Sometimes it’s worth it — worth it to be fully alive and active in my body or in my emotions, even though I’ll likely feel lousy the next day. But generally I try to do things in moderation. 

To look at me, you wouldn’t guess anything was amiss. This is what it means to be invisibly disabled.

It might sound like I’d be miserable all the time, but I’m not. There are bad days, and there are days when I grieve or feel like I’ll never feel good again, but they are pretty rare. This is my baseline and I’m pretty used to it, just like you’re used to yours. 

The most common treatments for fibromyalgia are anticonvulsants like gabapentin and pregabalin, thought to keep the nervous system from overreacting and causing symptoms (they’re also used to prevent epileptic seizures, and to treat shingles pain). I haven’t tried them, largely because I am so sensitive to medications, and these ones are notorious for being difficult to get used to (and more difficult to come off of if they don’t work). 

Instead, I take low doses of ibuprofen, which helps keep my baseline pain levels down. On bad days I have a whole menu of things to try: stretching, foam rolling or rolling against a pinky ball, THC or CBD tinctures, cannabis salves, heating pad, a bath with epsom salts, massage, chiropractic care, a nap. I’ve tried plenty of other things that don’t help, and I’m not looking for any advice. The best preventatives are good sleep, lots of hydration, and not too much (or too little) exercise or stress. But there’s only so much control I have — which is to say, not much. I’ve spent a lot of time coming to terms with the idea that some days I’ll feel like crap, but they will pass. 

The causes of fibromyalgia are still not well understood, but some research points to chronic stress, especially the kind of stress we may carry if we’ve experienced adversity and trauma before we become adults. It’s nice to see this research making its way into mainstream publications after doctors not taking fibromyalgia seriously for decades.

I’ve kept this to myself for a long time, not wanting to be treated as different or less capable — or conversely as some sort of inspiration, achieving so much in the face of adversity. Ultimately I can’t control what others think, and the older I get, the less energy I have for hiding. 

Favorite Things of 2019 by Beth Winegarner

Photo by freestocks.org on Unsplash.

As 2019 draws to a close, I wanted to look back and recommend a few of my favorite things from the year: books, music, television (this was a great year for television!), movies, podcasts, and so on. I hope you check some of these out, and if they’re already among your favorites of the year, let me know! At the end I share a handful of the books, TV and other things I’m looking forward to in 2020.

Books:
Pleasure Activism: The Politics of Feeling Good, Adrienne Maree Brown
The Book of Flora, Meg Elison
Those Who Wander: America’s Lost Street Kids, Vivian Ho
The Atlas of Reds and Blues, Devi Laskar
Burnout: The Secret to Unlocking the Stress Cycle, Emily and Amelia Nagoski
The Witches Are Coming, Lindy West

(You can hear me talking about Burnout on the GrottoPod podcast on Tuesday, Dec. 31. To keep up to date on that podcast, which I co-produce, sign up for our newsletter.)

Music:
Alcest, Spiritual Instinct
Lizzo, “Boys” (song)
Rope Sect, “Handsome Youth” (song)
Russian Circles, Blood Year
Chelsea Wolfe, Birth of Violence

Movies:
Hustlers
Last Black Man in San Francisco
Little Women
Marriage Story
The Farewell

Television:
Dark Crystal: Age of Resistance
Fleabag
Game of Thrones
(Season 8)
Gentleman Jack
Good Omens
His Dark Materials 
Killing Eve
Pose
Shrill
The Magicians
(Season 4)

Podcasts:
By-The-Bywater
How to Survive the End of the World
The Boiler Room
The Storm
This Podcast Will Kill You

YouTubers:
Bernadette Banner
Cathy Hay
Kitten Lady
James Welsh

Some Things I’m Looking Forward to in 2020:
Anne with an E, Season 3
Big Girl, Meg Elison
Breath, James Nestor
You Were Born For This, Chani Nicholas
She Votes: How U.S. Women Won Suffrage, Bridget Quinn
Parked, Danielle Svetcov
The Magicians Season 5

Poem a Week: Game by Beth Winegarner

Content warning: references to intimate partner abuse.

I: Nature

The fox crouches beneath cotoneaster fronds, 
red snout a strange berry.
A mouse scrabbles in the kudzu, 
tiny twitchings of her nose, whiskers, paws. 
The fox waits, can already taste 
the burst of meat and blood across his tongue.

She's so near he can smell the wet earth of her fur. 
In one motion he lunges, traps her in his jaw. 
Her terror makes his heart thrill.
She goes still in the cage of his canines. 
For long moments, months it seems,
(foxes cannot track time as well as they track prey) 
he holds her.

Is she alive? Curiosity swarms like flies in the fox’s ears
and his jaw falls open like a trapdoor, 
dropping the spit-slicked morsel into the duff. 
With no breath wasted the mouse dives back into the kudzu, 
deep beneath its sheltering barbed wire. 
Her babies will wonder why she brings home 
the scent of the hunter.

What do we say about foxes?
They cannot be trusted to protect hens and chicks.
The difference between the fox in the wood
and the fox in humans’ minds is this: 
the true animal does not grieve when its prey escapes, 
does not spend months wondering why she left.



II: In Fairytales

What makes a man terrorize the mother of his child, 
who saw Kali in the basins of blood 
the midwives carried from her bedroom,
who nearly died ushering in their lily-child?
What makes him tear the telephone wire from the wall,
arbiting connection to kin and rescue, as though
her screams would not carry from house to house?

We hire police to muzzle such men and cage them,
lawyers to seal the locks with guilt.

It is no wonder that some men dream themselves into
foxes or wolves, blade-toothed wild hounds, as though
doing so excuses them from the twin responsibilities of
conscience and respect. To live by hunger, lust,
the violence of bones snapped between strong jaws,
scent, the hunt: simple, isn’t it?

And all the throbbing, hot-veined creatures who
tremble in your presence are yours for the taking.


III: The Leash

Last night I dreamed we made a private joke between us.
While laughing, you wrapped a cord around my throat
so gentle and slow, I didn’t notice at first 
how tight it became until I could no longer 
slip my fingers underneath and pull it loose. 
We pretended that this, too, was funny.

Men have told me what to think, what to wear,
what to eat, what to buy, whom to love, what to say.
What not to say.
I have made their leashes my own.


IV: Wake Up

Sirens slice the night. 
Red and blue spins across your face.
Your hand still clutches the torn telephone line, 
copper wires the frayed end
of a marriage come undone,
ragged, separating, naked.

They enter in blue, sticks raised.
Behave as an animal and they will treat you like one.

V: Leaving

Just as the fox does not grieve and blame himself when the mouse escapes,
the mouse does not celebrate or feel proud. But we are not animals,
and I was secretly glad when I heard you left him.
More than secretly: I wanted to set bonfires on each mountaintop
to light your way to liberty. I longed to name each beacon
that would welcome you: Overleving, Sopravvivenza,
Vrijheid, Liberté, Freiheit. Freedom. Freedom. Freedom.

Poem A Week: False Garlic by Beth Winegarner

False garlic, Nothoscordum bivalve. Photo by Eric in SF.

False garlic, Nothoscordum bivalve. Photo by Eric in SF.

Kick your spurs
deep into winter's hide.
Gulp rainwater, splay your blades,
stabbing green into the black earth.
Claw through soft soil for the sun,
sky the color of a dishrag.

Nod white petals in summer,
shade blonde pistils
from the blistering light.
Flounce your beauty,
flirting through anodyne petticoats
that mask your ballistic blueprint.

Swell your bulbs deep,
masked in papery brown,
studded with seeds: cluster bombs
cocked to burst if they dig you up.
They'll have to savage the soil for years
before they can forget you.

An Annotated Bibliography of the Inside of My Head by Beth Winegarner

My friend Alex is running a blog circus now through December 15, 2019, in which we list books we find ourselves recommending over and over again: “You know those books that you can’t stop thinking about, won’t shut up about, and wish everyone around you would read? The ones that, if taken in aggregate, would tell people more about you than your resume?”

Here’s my list. If you’d like to participate, check out the details on Alex’s blog.

“Metalheads: Heavy Metal Music and Adolescent Alienation,” Jeffrey Jensen Arnett: Until I read this book, I thought I was the only person who listened to heavy metal because I found it soothing. 

“Radical Acceptance: Embracing Your Life With the Heart of a Buddha,” Tara Brach: I hated this book at first, but being able to accept yourself just as you are, right now, is the most radical and important steps toward self-love. You are worthy.

“The Deepest Well: Healing the Long-Term Effects of Childhood Adversity,” Nadine Burke Harris: The idea that childhood adversity leads to a lifetime of stress, pain and illness is being called the germ theory of the 21st century. Harris (now California’s surgeon general) describes the remedy. 

The Road to Nowhere series, Meg Elison: After a pandemic wipes out most of the women, and new babies become vanishingly rare, a story of how women and trans folk survive across the United States. 

“Come As You Are,” Emily Nagoski, and “Burnout,” Emily and Amelia Nagoski: In “Come As You Are,” Nagoski lays out the science to reassure us that our libidos, however they are, are normal. In “Burnout,” she and her twin sister give us tools for shedding the stress that gets in the way. 

“So You Want to Talk About Race,” Ijeoma Uluo: White people: we need to talk about race. Yes, it’s uncomfortable. But here are some facts and perspectives to get you started. 

“Cinderella Ate My Daughter,” Peg Orenstein: Disney’s “princess industrial complex” is motivated by profit and greed, and is teaching generations of girls toxic lessons in femininity.

“Care Work: Dreaming Disability Justice,” Leah Lakshmi Piepzna-Samarasinha: Healing doesn’t mean you go back to the way you were before. Trauma gives us superpowers. Communities of care help us thrive.

“Migraine,” Oliver Sacks: One of the world’s premier neurologists began having migraines as a young boy. He describes how they’re more than just headaches, but fascinating electrical storms in the brain and body.

“You Have the Right to Remain Fat,” Virgie Tovar: You are not required to be thin. You are not obligated to go on diets or control your eating. Fat-shaming leads to health disorders, but being fat doesn’t. Take up space and shine. 

“The Body Keeps the Score,” Bessell Van Der Kolk: Our bodies remember every terrifying thing that happened to us. Here’s how and why they do it, and how to start on the path to recovery.

Poem a Week: At 89 by Beth Winegarner

Photo by Jeff Turner on Flickr. Creative Commons.

Photo by Jeff Turner on Flickr. Creative Commons.

She looks at her reflection in the solid glass
of a nearby skyscraper.

She sees her curves and filigree framed
by its straight black borders, doubled by its impermeable sheen.

Born in 1914, she knows her young neighbors,
who sleekly shade the sunlight from her face, silhouette progress.

She's seen the blueprints that trace it out: there is no future
in her stone flanks, her bright crown.

She wonders if it's true that buildings earn
their souls when they survive a century

of bankers and barbarians, lawyers and legislators
who bow when they enter her marble chambers.

Who, when they look to her from below, see her face twice; her image
not trapped so much as giving that steel and glass a purpose.

Poem a Week: Summer Fever by Beth Winegarner

Photo by David Clode on Unsplash.

Photo by David Clode on Unsplash.

I am walking in the noon sun 
through the canyon, searching for evidence
of the fire that woke us last night. 

There are no remains – no charred
earth, no noseful of smoke or rivulets
of mud churned by the firefight.

So I go looking for blackberries
in the wood, thinking of the tart fruit
I devoured last summer, when I 

was newly pregnant. But the 
thickets have been cut back and picked 
over by birds and human hands. 

Last night you came clutching
a belated half-apology, seeking – what, 
exactly? The sun has long set

On the day for amends between us. 
the woman you seek no longer lives in this
house, this unfamiliar body. 

In the oppressive sky, a clucking raven
dives, hunting what meager morsels are
brave enough to emerge at midday

in this summer fever, 
more stunning for what it lacks: fog, 
noise, abundance, comfort, peace.

Poem a Week: Apocalypse Real Estate by Beth Winegarner

"eine Treppe" by YtvwlD. Creative commons.

"eine Treppe" by YtvwlD. Creative commons.

This is the house you want to own when shit goes down.
Its blast-proof windows will withstand bullets,
hydrogen bombs, political rhetoric,
and they come pre-sealed with duct tape.

The walls are rubberized concrete,
ready to shimmy when the big one hits,
ready to suck down the heat of climate change
or the cold of the sun's death.

These floors are melt-resistant steel,
just in case those terrorists fly a plane into them
or your ex sets fire to the place.

With the touch of a button the kitchen converts
to a bomb shelter, complete with compostable toilet,
water- and sun-free garden and tankless heated shower:
just the thing for when the Koreans nuke us
to high heaven or your stock bottoms out.

The paint and carpets will match themselves
to your clothes in case of a break-in;
those burglars will never spot you.

No, there's no bedroom.
But you don't actually sleep at night, do you?
There's much too much to worry about
for you to be able to get any shuteye, anyway.

Poem a Week: False Clover (Oxalis) by Beth Winegarner

Don't even think about wishing on
my green hearts. They fold
like the wings of three butterflies,
heads in a huddle. Never four,
not like the one you think I am
when you spy me under
the redwoods' emerald umbrella.

They don't call me sour grass
for nothing. In the wood I am sorrel,
a word like a mouthful of spring;
at home I choke your tender
peas and parsley for all I'm worth.
With each drift of yellow petals
I'm building up my buttercup brigade.

Go on. Pull me. I like it so much I
shower seeds so I can do it again.
Smother me with your thickest mulch;
I will dig my way into the sunlight.
Purge is another name for propagate.
When you found me, you were right
on one count: I can change your luck.

Poem a Week: Basket Stinkhorn by Beth Winegarner

Several basket stinkhorn mushrooms, Clathrus ruber, at varying stages of development.

Several basket stinkhorn mushrooms, Clathrus ruber, at varying stages of development.

Alien egg, or bee-spun globe
the size of a toddler's head
sleeping in its bed
of sedums and mud.

At first no more than a marshmallow,
round and mute as an amnion.
Inside, a fungus fossil blooms
a basket of brains.

Come closer, whiff the perfume
of putrescence, a dead ringer
for summer-baked carrion.
You'll catch more flies

with stench than maple syrup
and this is no waffle worth eating.
Stand aside. Let the insects
scatter saprobes as they soar.